Menu

Rivalry · Japanese Grand Prix 1989

Two teammates, one chicane

Senna and Prost, both McLaren drivers, collided at Suzuka with the title at stake. Senna crossed the line first and was disqualified; the title went to Prost.

Date
22 October 1989
Circuit
Suzuka
Read
7 min
Two red and white McLarens lead the field on a wet track, throwing up spray.
Senna ahead of Prost at the start of the Belgian GP, 27.08.1989.
  1. Before the second-to-last race of 1989 Prost had 76 counting points and Senna 60. Senna had to win both remaining races.18415
  2. On lap 47 Senna attacked into the ChicaneA sequence of two or three short corners in alternating directions.In the glossary →, Prost turned in, and the two McLarens locked together.251 Senna rejoined by skipping the chicane and crossed the line first.231213
  3. Senna was DSQDisqualifiedThe result is cancelled for breaking the rules.In the glossary → for missing the chicane.23412 The FIA Court of Appeal upheld it and added a $100,000 fine.34122 Prost was champion.1713

Before Suzuka

In 1989 Alain Prost and Ayrton Senna drove for the same team, McLaren-Honda. The title counted each driver's best 11 results from 16 races.461219 Prost scored 81 points that season, but only 76 counted.615

Because of that rule a third place was already worth nothing to Prost: any new score would only replace his worst counted result, the 4 points for third in Jerez. Senna had 60 and nothing to drop. Two wins at 9 points each would take him to 78, two more than Prost.6415

There was no trust left between the teammates. According to Prost, before the race at Imola they agreed not to attack each other before the first corner, and Senna broke that at the restart. Senna said there was no agreement.sources disagree: 7616 In July Prost announced he was leaving McLaren,14619 and at Monza, during the Italian Grand Prix weekend, it was confirmed that his next team would be Ferrari.2122

The race

Senna took Pole positionFirst place on the grid. It goes to the fastest driver in qualifying.In the glossary → with 1:38.041,2206 Prost was second, 1.730 s slower.206 Prost made the better start and led.234 By lap 11 he was 4.9 s clear; each driver stopped once for tyres, Prost on lap 21, Senna on lap 23.one source: 2

After the stops Senna started to close in. Sources differ on how close he was by lap 40: 0.42 s or about a second.sources disagree: 23

The chicane

On lap 47, seven laps from the end, Senna went for the pass into the chicane before the pit straight. Prost completed 46 laps, which is why some sources say «lap 46».251 Senna dived down the inside, Prost turned in to the ApexThe point of a corner where the car is closest to the inside edge.In the glossary →, the cars locked together, both engines stalled and the McLarens stopped at the entrance to the escape road.2312

«This time I said before the race that if this happens I would not open the door.»26

Alain Prost · after the race, 22.10.1989

Prost climbed out straight away. Marshals pushed Senna's McLaren, he bump-started the engine and rejoined through the escape road, past the chicane.231213 Whether that push was legal is still argued: the rules allowed it if the car was stopped in a dangerous place.sources disagree: 62

Senna drove nearly a full lap with a damaged nose, pitted for a new one and rejoined about 5 s behind Alessandro Nannini's Benetton.32 He passed Nannini at the same chicane on lap 51 (lap 50 in another account)sources disagree: 23 and took the chequered flag first. He was not allowed onto the podium.65

«Somebody who was there closed the door. I was the moral winner.»one source: 2

Ayrton Senna · after the race, 22.10.1989

The ruling

The StewardsThe race judges. They review incidents and hand out penalties.In the glossary → disqualified Senna for missing the chicane: he rejoined the track somewhere other than where he left it.23412 The push itself was not penalised. According to Joe Saward, the version of the decision that reached the Court of Appeal was a different one, citing Article 63 of the Code on safety.one source: 5

The win went to Nannini, the first and only one of his career. Riccardo Patrese was second and Thierry Boutsen third, both in Williams cars.162

Sources disagree on whether FISA president Jean-Marie Balestre was in the stewards' room. RaceFans writes that he «joined the stewards». 8W Forix cites two books: according to Heinz Prüller, FISA officials insisted he was not with them; according to Terry Lovell, he came in but took no part in the decision.sources disagree: 613

Appeal and winter

McLaren appealed the same day. The case went to the FIA International Court of Appeal in Paris, which sat on Friday 27 October.56 The court did more than uphold the disqualification: it fined Senna $100,000 and gave him a six-month suspended ban, citing earlier offences.34122

«We went there expecting to defend a case of shop-lifting, and we were faced defending car theft, shoplifting, rape, murder and pillage.»one source: 5

Ron Dennis, McLaren team boss · on the Court of Appeal hearing, November 1989
  1. 22.10.1989Race day. Disqualification; McLaren appeals the same day.56
  2. 27.10.1989FIA Court of Appeal, Paris.56
  3. late OctoberRuling: disqualification upheld, $100,000, six months suspended.34122
  4. 10.11.1989Senna accuses FISA and Balestre at a press conference in Brazil.one source: 8
  5. 07.12.1989FIA World Council: no 1990 superlicence until Senna withdraws the accusations.one source: 8
  6. February 1990McLaren pays the fine, FISA publishes a statement from Senna, and he is on the entry list.89

A year later

Prost was the 1989 champion, his third title,1716 and moved to Ferrari. On 21 October 1990 they met at Suzuka again, now in different teams. Senna started from pole, Prost second. Both went out at the first corner of the first lap after a collision, and the title went to Senna.1112

A year after that, at Suzuka on 20 October 1991, Senna said he had decided beforehand: if Prost got the better start, he would not give way at the first corner.910

«If tomorrow Prost beats me off the line, at the first corner I will go for it, and he better not turn in.»one source: 9

Ayrton Senna on Suzuka 1990 · Suzuka, 20.10.1991

Where the sources disagree

The Imola agreement

Prost and Marlboro's John Hogan say there was an agreement; Senna denied it. [7, 6, 16]

Senna's gap on lap 40

Motor Sport says 0.42 s; GrandPrix.com says «about a second». [2, 3]

Whether the push was legal

RaceFans says the rules allowed the push; Motor Sport says not once the car sat in the escape road. [6, 2]

Lap of the pass on Nannini

Lap 51 according to Motor Sport, lap 50 according to GrandPrix.com. [2, 3]

Balestre in the stewards' room

RaceFans writes that Balestre «joined the stewards». 8W Forix cites two books: according to Heinz Prüller, FISA officials insisted he was not with them; according to Terry Lovell, he came in but took no part in the decision. [6, 13]

Sources

Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.

  1. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1989 Japanese Grand Prix results”
  2. Motor Sport, 1989-12: “A flash in Japan — 1989 Japanese Grand Prix race report” (David Tremayne)
  3. GrandPrix.com, 1989-10-22: “Japanese GP, 1989 — race report” (Joe Saward)
  4. Autosport, 2019-10-22: “When F1's fiercest rivalry first overspilled” (Nigel Roebuck)
  5. GrandPrix.com, 1989-12-01: “McLaren versus Jean-Marie Balestre” (Joe Saward)
  6. RaceFans, 2014-10-22: “Prost's Suzuka chicanery denies Senna the title (1989 Japanese GP flashback)” (Keith Collantine)
  7. Formula1.com, 2014-04-28: “Ron Dennis on Senna — part one: the early years”
  8. Motor Sport, 2020-02-15: “When Ayrton Senna was nearly banned from F1” (Graham Keilloh)
  9. GrandPrix.com, 1991: “Ayrton Senna attacks Jean-Marie Balestre” (Joe Saward)
  10. Motor Sport, 1991-12: “The other side of Senna — his rage at Prost after Suzuka 1990 crash” (David Tremayne)
  11. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1990 Japanese Grand Prix results”
  12. Atlas F1, 2002-02-13: “The FIA's International Court of Appeal: Final Answer? (Part III)” (Richard O'Keefe)
  13. 8W Forix: “When? — 1989 (the 1989 World Championship)”
  14. Motor Sport, 1989-08: “Around and about, August 1989”
  15. Outlap (calculation from Jolpica F1 results): “Prost 1989: counting results under the best-11 rule — our calculation from the 1989 results”
  16. Motor Sport, 1990-01: “Alain Prost — an interview with the new World Champion”
  17. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1989 drivers' championship standings (final)”
  18. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1989 drivers' standings after round 14 (Spanish GP)”
  19. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1989 season calendar”
  20. Formula1.com: “1989 Japanese Grand Prix — starting grid”
  21. GrandPrix.com, 1989-09-10: “Italian GP, 1989 — race report”
  22. Motor Sport, 1989-10: “Food for thought — 1989 Italian Grand Prix race report”

More stories

All stories →
  • 1997Jerez · Season finale

    The decider in Jerez

    Schumacher and Villeneuve came to the last race one point apart. On lap 48 Schumacher turned into his rival, went off and lost the title, and a month later the FIA excluded him from the season's standings.

    61 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 47
    • one source: 10
    • sources disagree: 4
  • 1993Donington · Upset

    Donington 1993: Senna's lap

    A wet track, a customer Ford engine and fourth on the grid. In one lap Ayrton Senna passed four rivals, then won a race in which Williams got lost in their own pit stops.

    51 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 26
    • sources disagree: 2
  • 2021Abu Dhabi · Scandal

    Abu Dhabi 2021: the one lap that decided a championship

    Latifi's crash, the race director's call on lapped cars and Verstappen's last-lap pass. How the 2021 finale became modern Formula 1's loudest officiating row, and what it cost Michael Masi.

    39 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 16
    • sources disagree: 0
  • 1991Spa · Upset

    Spa 1991: Schumacher's debut that lasted a few hundred metres

    A Jordan driver is in jail over a gas canister, a rookie who has never seen the track learns it by bicycle, and a week after the race one word in a letter sends him to Benetton.

    51 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 26
    • sources disagree: 2
Photos: authors and licences