Menu

Season finale · European Grand Prix 1997

The decider in Jerez

Schumacher and Villeneuve came to the last race one point apart. On lap 48 Schumacher turned into his rival, went off and lost the title, and a month later the FIA excluded him from the season's standings.

Date
26 October 1997
Circuit
Jerez
Read
7 min
A red Ferrari on track, the driver raising a hand from the cockpit; a blurred chequered flag in the foreground.
Michael Schumacher (Ferrari) at the 1997 German Grand Prix, Hockenheim.
  1. Before the 1997 finale Schumacher had 78 points and Villeneuve 77.1011302 Schumacher only had to finish ahead of his rival; Villeneuve had to score and beat Schumacher.42
  2. On lap 48 Villeneuve attacked at Dry Sac, Schumacher turned into him and ended up in the gravel.342721 Villeneuve finished third and took the title.23
  3. The FIA World Council excluded Schumacher from the 1997 standings but let him keep his wins, with no fine and no ban.251863225186

Before Jerez

The 1997 finale moved from Estoril to Jerez after the FIA said the Portuguese circuit had not met its requirements.731 Going into the last race Jacques Villeneuve (Williams) had seven wins, Michael Schumacher (Ferrari) five.24

At Suzuka, two weeks before the finale, Villeneuve failed to slow for waved yellows in Saturday practice. It was his fourth such offence of the year, and a suspended ban from Monza kicked in.208 Williams appealed, Villeneuve raced and finished fifth, but on 16 October, under FIA pressure, the team withdrew the appeal. He lost those 2 points: 77 to Schumacher's 78.1011302

On equal points Villeneuve would rank higher on wins. So Schumacher only had to finish ahead of Villeneuve, and Villeneuve had to score and finish ahead of Schumacher.42 Williams had already won the Constructors' Cup in Japan.91

Three identical laps

In qualifying Villeneuve, Schumacher and Heinz-Harald Frentzen set exactly the same time, 1:21.072, to the thousandth.123 Pole went to Villeneuve because he set it first.one source: 4 Damon Hill's Arrows was fourth, 0.058 s slower.123

The race

Schumacher took the lead at the start and Frentzen got past Villeneuve, then, on team orders, let him through early in the race.341 Sources differ on whether it was lap 7 or lap 8.sources disagree: 143 Schumacher pitted on laps 22 and 43, Villeneuve on laps 23 and 44.14 Between the first stops Frentzen led and held Schumacher up.13

Norberto Fontana, in a Ferrari-engined Sauber, let Schumacher by and then held Villeneuve up, by an estimated 2.5 to 3 seconds.2243 In 2006 Fontana said it was Jean Todt's order; Sauber and Ferrari deny it.sources disagree: 30 By the lap data, Schumacher led by 3.2 s after lap 1 and 5.2 s after lap 20, and by under half a second after lap 47.13

Dry Sac

On lap 48 Villeneuve braked later and dived down the inside into the Dry Sac hairpin. Schumacher turned into him: the Ferrari's right front wheel hit the Williams' left sidepod. The Ferrari beached itself in the gravel and Villeneuve drove on.342721 The result sheet shows Schumacher with 47 laps and «collision».113 Sources give the time of the impact as 15:08 or 15:12.sources disagree: 274

«Either Michael had his eyes closed or his hands slipped on the steering wheel.»one source: 13

Jacques Villeneuve · Jerez, after the race, 26.10.1997

«Jacques cut in and didn't try to brake at all. Certainly, I closed the door.»one source: 14

Michael Schumacher · after the race, 26–27.10.1997

The impact tore the Williams' battery from its mountings; it hung on by its wires.one source: 3 Villeneuve feared a failure and backed off: on laps 48 to 50 he ran 1:27 to 1:29 while the McLarens did 1:25.one source: 1

The finish

On lap 67 David Coulthard let his teammate Mika Häkkinen by,1222829 and on the last lap Villeneuve let both McLarens through. Häkkinen took his first career win; Villeneuve finished third.1133 With 81 points he was world champion.23 Gerhard Berger finished fourth in the last race of his career.1133

On 8 November The Times published Williams radio transcripts and alleged a deal with McLaren.221726 The recordings were circulated by Ferrari as part of Schumacher's defence.61726

Did McLaren help Williams? Sources disagree. Officially, no: the FIA World Council threw out the collusion charge, finding the result «was not fixed».182463 Later it was partly admitted. Coulthard said in 2021 that Ron Dennis had agreed to help Williams with the title if needed.one source: 28 McLaren's Jo Ramirez recalls Patrick Head coming to their garage to say Jacques would not resist.one source: 29

The ruling

The StewardsThe race judges. They review incidents and hand out penalties.In the glossary → in Jerez called the collision a racing incident.1314234 The next day the FIA summoned Schumacher to an extraordinary World Council.1423 At first he blamed Villeneuve,14430 and on 28 October at Maranello he admitted a mistake.15521

«I am human like everyone else and unfortunately I made a mistake.»15521

Michael Schumacher · Maranello, 28.10.1997

In Germany the RTL channel ran a phone poll: of 63,081 callers, 28% said they no longer supported Schumacher.1621

On 11 November the FIA World Council met in Slough near London.256 Schumacher was excluded from the final 1997 standings, and Frentzen became runner-up.2518632 The race results, Schumacher's five wins and Ferrari's Constructors' points stood.1863 There was no fine and no ban for 1998.25186 The Council found the act deliberate but not premeditated,251863 and required Schumacher to take part in an FIA road-safety campaign in 1998.3619 Sources describe its size differently.sources disagree: 36

«Although the actions were deliberate they were not premeditated.»251863

Max Mosley, FIA president · Slough, 11.11.1997

Mosley called it «much more than a slap on the wrist»,one source: 18 but part of the press thought it far too lenient.one source: 19

  1. 26.10.1997Race. Stewards: a racing incident, no further action.1314234
  2. 27.10.1997Acting on the race director's report, the FIA summons Schumacher to an extraordinary World Council.1423
  3. 28.10.1997Maranello: Schumacher admits a mistake.15521
  4. 08.11.1997The Times publishes Williams radio transcripts and alleges a deal with McLaren.221726
  5. 11.11.1997FIA World Council in Slough: Schumacher is excluded from the 1997 championship standings.2518632

An echo of Adelaide

British reports from Jerez recalled the 1994 finale in Adelaide. Then Schumacher led Damon Hill by one point, they collided, both retired, and the title went to Schumacher.322526 Schumacher himself rejected the comparison with 1994.one source: 5

Where the sources disagree

When Frentzen let Villeneuve by

Lap 7 according to l'Unità and RaceFans, lap 8 according to the Jolpica lap data. [1, 4, 3]

An order to hold Villeneuve up

Fontana said in 2006 that the order came from Jean Todt. Sauber and Ferrari deny it. [30]

Time of the collision

15:08 according to Motor Sport, 15:12 according to l'Unità. [27, 4]

Size of the safety campaign

RaceFans says «seven days in 1998»; l'Unità says the campaign ran «in seven European capitals». [3, 6]

Sources

Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.

  1. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1997 European Grand Prix results and laps”
  2. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1997 drivers' standings”
  3. RaceFans, 2017-10-26: “Villeneuve takes title as Schumacher's attack gets him thrown out (1997 European Grand Prix)” (Keith Collantine)
  4. l'Unità, 1997-10-27: “l'Unità, 27 ottobre 1997, p. 22”
  5. l'Unità, 1997-10-29: “l'Unità, 29 ottobre 1997, p. 16”
  6. l'Unità, 1997-11-12: “l'Unità, 12 novembre 1997, p. 17”
  7. Atlas F1, 1997-05-15: “From Estoril to Jerez back to Estoril; TWR Arrows dealt another blow”
  8. Atlas F1, 1997-10-11: “Villeneuve takes Suzuka pole but risks disqualification”
  9. Atlas F1, 1997-10-12: “Title challenge ends at the next race: Jerez”
  10. Atlas F1, 1997-10-15: “Mosley on Villeneuve: withdraw appeal; Berger to retire; Minardi drivers; Dome?; Stewart to test Stewart”
  11. Atlas F1, 1997-10-16: “Villeneuve drops appeal”
  12. Atlas F1, 1997-10-25: “First three set the same time (Europe GP)”
  13. Atlas F1, 1997-10-26: “Villeneuve World Champion 1997; Hakkinen wins his first race”
  14. Atlas F1, 1997-10-27: “Schumacher to face FIA council”
  15. Atlas F1, 1997-10-28: “Coulthard praises Williams at Senna trial; Schumacher admits mistake”
  16. Atlas F1, 1997-10-29: “Top three at Williams testify; Schumacher has lost some fans”
  17. Atlas F1, 1997-11-09: “Schumacher gets ready for hearing, Williams/McLaren deny allegations”
  18. Atlas F1, 1997-11-11: “Schumacher loses his second place; Williams and McLaren cleared; Schumacher is next year's title favourite”
  19. Atlas F1, 1997-11-12: “FIA decision brings up heavy criticism”
  20. GrandPrix.com, 1997-10-13: “Villeneuve in trouble”
  21. GrandPrix.com, 1997-11-03: “The lost honor”
  22. GrandPrix.com, 1997-11-10: “Race-rigging or press manipulation?” (Joe Saward)
  23. GrandPrix.com, 1997-11-03: “Face-saving at the FIA” (Joe Saward)
  24. GrandPrix.com, 1997-11-17: “A decent decision” (Joe Saward)
  25. BBC (BBC News), 1997-11-11: “Schumacher loses championship runner-up crown”
  26. BBC (BBC News, Sport), 1997-11-11: “Schumacher and F1 on trial”
  27. Motor Sport, 1997-12: “F1 1997: the same old story?” (Nigel Roebuck)
  28. Motor Sport, 2021-06: “David Coulthard on Mika Häkkinen: my greatest rival”
  29. McLaren (heritage), 2023-10-23: “Mika's silver service”
  30. The Race, 2021-12-12: “Inside stories from F1's last title-deciding scandal” (Josh Suttill)
  31. The Irish Times, 1997-07-23: “Portugal loses its Grand Prix”
  32. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 1994 Australian Grand Prix results”

More stories

All stories →
  • 1989Suzuka · Rivalry

    Two teammates, one chicane

    Senna and Prost, both McLaren drivers, collided at Suzuka with the title at stake. Senna crossed the line first and was disqualified; the title went to Prost.

    43 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 31
    • one source: 7
    • sources disagree: 5
  • 1994Scandal

    Benetton 1994: a title under investigation

    A hidden menu option in the software, an ignored black flag, a pit-lane fire and a worn plank under the floor. How Michael Schumacher won his first title by a single point, in between FIA hearings.

    34 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 18
    • one source: 15
    • sources disagree: 1
  • 2021Abu Dhabi · Scandal

    Abu Dhabi 2021: the one lap that decided a championship

    Latifi's crash, the race director's call on lapped cars and Verstappen's last-lap pass. How the 2021 finale became modern Formula 1's loudest officiating row, and what it cost Michael Masi.

    39 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 16
    • sources disagree: 0
  • 2002Spielberg · Scandal

    Austria 2002: the win given away over the radio

    Rubens Barrichello led the whole race and, a few metres from the line, let Michael Schumacher through on Ferrari's orders. Jeering grandstands, an upside-down podium, a million-dollar fine and a ban on team orders that lasted eight seasons.

    35 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 11
    • sources disagree: 1
Photos: authors and licences