Menu

Scandal

The first overspend: how Red Bull broke the 2021 budget cap

In the cost cap's first year, the FIA found a 'minor overspend' in the champion team's accounts. A $7m fine, a 10% cut in aero testing and a row over whether it amounted to cheating.

Read
8 min
Sources
18
Claims
35
A glass building with a large charging-bull logo on a blue and yellow wall.
The entrance to the Red Bull Racing factory in Milton Keynes, March 2013.

In 2021 Formula 1 lived with a spending limit for the first time. In the autumn of 2022 it emerged that the only team to go over it was the one whose driver had won that season's world title.45

What the cost cap is

The 2021 spending limit was $145m. The FIA World Motor Sport Council approved the figure on 27 May 2020. The original plan had been $175m, but the COVID-19 pandemic hit the teams' finances and the threshold was lowered.12 It was then due to fall further: $140m in 2022 and $135m for 2023–2025.12

Not everything counts. Drivers' salaries are outside the cap,23 as are marketing costs and the salaries of a team's three highest-paid executives.one source: 3 Teams calculate the rest themselves and submit a report to the FIA, which the Cost Cap Administration then audits. For everyone, 2021 was the first year of the full application of these rules.one source: 810

That same season Max Verstappen won the drivers' title for Red Bull, finishing eight points ahead of Lewis Hamilton: 395.5 to 387.5.one source: 16 So when the overspend became known, some rivals went as far as calling for Verstappen to be stripped of the title.one source: 18

A dark blue Red Bull car numbered 33 on track, side view.
Max Verstappen in the Red Bull RB16B, Austrian Grand Prix, Spielberg, 2 July 2021.

10 October: a "minor overspend"

On 10 October 2022 the FIA published the results of its review. Seven of the ten teams received certificates of compliance. Aston Martin, the FIA found, had committed a procedural breach. Red Bull had committed both a procedural breach and a minor overspend breach, meaning less than 5%.45 Williams had a separate procedural breach, settled back in May.45 On that occasion the team got away with a $25,000 fine for a late submission.one source: 17

What was Red Bull facing? For a minor overspend the regulations allowed points deductions, suspension from individual sessions other than the race, limits on aerodynamic testing and a lower cap for the following year.one source: 17

Red Bull noted the findings "with surprise and disappointment" and insisted that its submission had been below the cap.56 The FIA did not give the size of the overspend at that point, and until the end of October the paddock could only guess how much money was involved.45

Brown's letter

The loudest voice was McLaren chief Zak Brown. On 12 October he wrote to FIA president Mohammed Ben Sulayem that an overspend constituted cheating, because it offered a significant advantage. Brown named no teams.67 In his view, whoever spent more had gained an unfair advantage in developing the car, and that called for a sporting penalty. Among his suggestions for a minor overspend were a 20% cut in wind-tunnel and CFD work and a reduction of the following year's cap by the amount overspent plus an additional fine.67 Brown also sent a copy of the letter to Stefano Domenicali.one source: 7

A smiling man in a dark jacket against blurred grandstands.
Zak Brown at the 24 Hours of Daytona, January 2022.

28 October: the agreement

The FIA and Red Bull signed an Accepted Breach Agreement (ABA) on 26 October and announced it on 28 October.8913 The public summary of the agreement finally put numbers on the table.

Red Bull had declared £114,293,000 of costs subject to the cap. The auditors found £5,607,000 that the team had wrongly excluded from the calculation or adjusted.one source: 8 The document states Red Bull's 2021 cap in pounds: £118,036,000. After the FIA's recalculation the team was over it by £1,864,000, or 1.6%.one source: 8 In dollar terms the press reported different figures: AP wrote of $1.8m, Sky Sports of $2.2m.sources disagree: 18128

The list of disputed items runs to 13 points. It includes catering, bonuses, the cost of using Power unitThe combustion engine together with the electrical part and the battery.In the glossary →, travel, maintenance and a clerical error in calculating costs recharged by Red Bull Powertrains.one source: 8 The FIA dealt separately with the tax question and acknowledged that, had Red Bull correctly applied a notional tax credit of £1,431,348, the overspend would have been just £432,652, or 0.37%.one source: 8

The penalty had three parts. A $7m fine, payable within 30 days. A 10% cut in aerodynamic testing for 12 months, meaning fewer wind-tunnel hours and fewer CFD runs. And Red Bull covers the Cost Cap Administration's costs of preparing the agreement.812

The document also contains mitigating language. The FIA stated there was no accusation or evidence that Red Bull had acted in bad faith, dishonestly or fraudulently.813 The decision is final and cannot be appealed.one source: 8

Aston Martin: a fine without an overspend

Aston Martin's case looked quite different. Its agreement was signed on 25 October. The team's spending was within the cap; the problem was the reporting, with 12 items treated incorrectly. They included costs for the new headquarters, the new simulator, additional wind-tunnel fees and catering at the factory. The fine was $450,000.1011

Two truths

Red Bull team principal Christian Horner spoke sharply but did not rebel:

"We accept the penalties, begrudgingly, but we accept them."1312

He called the sanctions draconian.121314 He saw the sporting part as the most painful: by his estimate, losing 10% of aero testing would be worth between a quarter and half a second a lap.121314 Horner explained where the team and the FIA had disagreed: tax, catering and sick pay.1318 He went through the sick-pay case separately. Red Bull had treated payments to an ill employee as an excludable cost. "Had the person died, and thankfully they didn't, the cost would have been excluded," Horner said.one source: 18 In his words, "not one penny was spent on performance".one source: 18 He added that there had been no intent and certainly no cheating, and that some rivals probably owed Red Bull an apology.one source: 12 In his view, rivals had pushed for a harsh penalty precisely because it gave them an advantage.one source: 13 Not everyone in the paddock sided with Brown: Alpine team boss Otmar Szafnauer said it was time for the accusations to stop.one source: 12

A man in a dark jacket on stage next to a microphone stand.
Christian Horner at F1 Live in Trafalgar Square, London, 12 July 2017.

The rivals' case had been set out most clearly by Brown before the verdict: an overspend gives an advantage both in the current car and in developing the next one.67 The FIA's document took neither extreme position. It recorded the overspend, but called it minor and said it had found no ill intent.813

What it changed

The first year of the cap produced the first overspend case with real sanctions, and it concerned the champion's team.one source: 810one source: 16 The episode also showed how complex the accounting behind the round figure of $145m is. Three of the ten teams had procedural breaches,4545 and the FIA itself wrote that the regulations are very complex.one source: 810

The penalty did not hold Red Bull back. The wind-tunnel restriction ran for 12 months,812 and in 2023 Red Bull won 21 of 22 races.one source: 15 So the argument over how much 10% of wind-tunnel time is really worth never got a clear answer.

Where the sources disagree

Overspend in dollars

According to the FIA document, Red Bull exceeded the cap by £1,864,000. AP wrote of $1.8m, which looks like the pound figure with a dollar sign; Sky Sports wrote of $2.2m, probably converting pounds into dollars. [18, 12, 8]

Sources

Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.

  1. The Race, 2020-05-27: “FIA officially approves major F1 rules overhaul”
  2. Motor Sport Magazine, 2020-05-27: “$145m cost cap approved for F1 in 2021, with more limits on testing and development”
  3. Autocar India, 2020-05-28: “F1's new rules explained: lower cost cap, sliding scale aero and more”
  4. FIA, 2022-10-10: “FIA completes review under the 2021 FIA Formula 1 Financial Regulations”
  5. ESPN, 2022-10-10: “FIA finds Red Bull guilty of 'minor' overspend of 2021 budget cap (Laurence Edmondson)”
  6. The Irish Times / Reuters, 2022-10-17: “Red Bull budget-cap breach amounts to cheating, says McLaren boss (Reuters)”
  7. Speedcafe, 2022-10-18: “In full: Brown's letter to the FIA”
  8. FIA (Cost Cap Administration), 2022-10-28: “RBR Public Summary ABA / Article 6.32”
  9. FIA, 2022-10-28: “Accepted Breach Agreement between Red Bull Racing Team and the FIA for Breach of the 2021 FIA Formula One Financial Regulations”
  10. FIA (Cost Cap Administration), 2022-10-28: “AMR Public Summary ABA / Article 6.32”
  11. The Race, 2022-10-28: “Aston Martin's F1 budget cap breach penalty announced”
  12. Sky Sports, 2022-10-29: “Red Bull chief Christian Horner says team 'begrudgingly' accept 2021 F1 cost cap breach punishment”
  13. Formula1.com, 2022-10-28: “Horner on why he feels Red Bull's Cost Cap breach penalties were 'draconian' – and why his team have accepted them”
  14. PlanetF1, 2022-10-28: “Christian Horner: Red Bull budget-cap penalty 'could cost half a second a lap'”
  15. Jolpica F1 API, 2023-11-26: “Red Bull results, 2023 season”
  16. Jolpica F1 API, 2021-12-12: “2021 final driver standings”
  17. The Race, 2022-10-10: “Red Bull breached F1 budget cap, penalty not yet decided (Scott Mitchell-Malm, Matt Beer)”
  18. Associated Press via MyNorthwest, 2022-10-28: “Red Bull fined $7 million for overspending F1 cost cap (AP)”

More stories

All stories →
  • 2021Abu Dhabi · Scandal

    Abu Dhabi 2021: the one lap that decided a championship

    Latifi's crash, the race director's call on lapped cars and Verstappen's last-lap pass. How the 2021 finale became modern Formula 1's loudest officiating row, and what it cost Michael Masi.

    39 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 16
    • sources disagree: 0
  • 2021Spa · Scandal

    Spa 2021: the race that never was

    Three hours of rain, a few laps behind the safety car and half points. How the shortest race in Formula 1 history left fans without a refund and forced a rewrite of the rules.

    43 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 28
    • one source: 14
    • sources disagree: 1
  • 2008Singapore · Scandal

    The crash that was ordered

    Nelson Piquet Jr. crashed on purpose to bring out the safety car and help his teammate Alonso win. The truth came out a year later, and the court cases are still going.

    64 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 51
    • one source: 7
    • sources disagree: 6
  • 2007Scandal

    Spygate 2007: how McLaren lost $100 million

    780 pages of Ferrari secrets, a copy shop in Woking, a row in Budapest and a record FIA fine. How McLaren were thrown out of the constructors' championship while their drivers kept every point.

    33 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 10
    • sources disagree: 1