Menu

Scandal · Singapore Grand Prix 2008

The crash that was ordered

Nelson Piquet Jr. crashed on purpose to bring out the safety car and help his teammate Alonso win. The truth came out a year later, and the court cases are still going.

Date
28 September 2008
Circuit
Singapore
Read
8 min
Ferrari mechanics in red crowd around a car behind the pit-lane mesh fence at night.
The Ferrari pit during Massa's fuel-hose incident, Singapore Grand Prix, 28.09.2008.
  1. Alonso started 15th and pitted as early as lap 12.3201 Two laps later his teammate Piquet crashed on purpose, the Safety carA car that comes out after an accident and leads the field at reduced speed.In the glossary → came out and Alonso won.3817
  2. A year later Piquet told the FIA the crash had been ordered by team bosses.310 Renault got a suspended DSQDisqualifiedThe result is cancelled for breaking the rules.In the glossary →, Briatore an indefinite ban and Symonds five years.20223
  3. Hamilton won the title by one point from Massa.one source: 2 Massa is still in court; the UK Supreme Court hearing is set for February 2027.3438

The first night race

The Singapore Grand Prix on 28 September 2008 was Formula 1's first night race.14 Going in, Hamilton had 78 points and Massa 77, while Alonso's Renault was seventh on 28.23

Alonso was quick in practice, but early in the second part of qualifying his fuel system failed and he started 15th.35 Renault fuelled him very light, for only 12 to 15 laps.310

The race

Alonso pitted as early as lap 12 and rejoined last.3201 Two laps later his teammate Nelson Piquet Jr. hit the wall on the exit of turn 17.38 The FIA's official decision says lap 14; some reports say lap 13.sources disagree: 32076

A crane lifts a wrecked Renault while marshals in orange stand nearby.
Piquet's wrecked Renault is lifted away, Singapore, 28.09.2008.

In 2008 the Pit laneThe separate road along the pits. A speed limit applies there.In the glossary → closed when the safety car came out, until the field had lined up behind it.39 Rivals could only refuel later, while Alonso, already fuelled, rose to fifth.320 Rosberg and Kubica, running out of fuel, pitted while the lane was closed and were penalised.97 Sources differ on the type of penalty.sources disagree: 976

Leader Massa left his stop with the fuel hose still attached and stopped at the end of the pit lane while mechanics ran to pull it off.76 Sources differ on how many mechanics he knocked over.sources disagree: 76

Jarno Trulli led until his stop on lap 33, and from lap 34 Alonso was in front.571 He won, Rosberg was second and Hamilton third. Massa finished 13th with no points.17

How it came out

As early as 2008 the driver's father, Nelson Piquet, privately told an FIA official the crash might have been staged. The FIA decided there was not enough evidence.312 On 26 July 2009, the day of the Hungarian Grand Prix, he went to the FIA directly.313 On 30 July Piquet Jr. gave a sworn statement in Paris.310 Only after that did it emerge that he had been dropped, and on 18 August Renault named his replacement.141315

«Mr. Symonds, in the presence of Mr. Briatore, asked me if I would be willing to sacrifice my race for the team by "causing a safety car".»11103

Nelson Piquet Jr. · statement to the FIA, 30.07.2009

The spot was chosen because cranes would take long to reach it, making a safety car certain.one source: 3 The telemetry showed Piquet applied the throttle earlier and harder, and when the wheels spun he went back to full throttle and held it.one source: 3

Accounts differ on whose idea it was. According to Piquet, on race day he was called to Briatore's office, where Symonds, with Briatore present, asked him to «cause a safety car».11103 Symonds maintained that Piquet himself raised the idea the day before, on Saturday; he did not answer the stewards' key questions.sources disagree: 31819 Witness X, a Renault employee whose name was withheld, heard Symonds discuss Briatore's plan on Saturday and objected. His evidence was key to the finding against Briatore.325

A man in a Renault shirt and headphones stands with his arms folded.
Flavio Briatore at the Chinese GP, 19.10.2008.

In late August the Belgian GP StewardsThe race judges. They review incidents and hand out penalties.In the glossary → interviewed Renault staff.313 On 11 September Renault and Briatore filed a criminal complaint in France against both Piquets, but by 16 September the team had told the FIA it would not contest the charges, and Briatore and Symonds had left.1617315

The ruling

On 21 September 2009 the FIA World Council gave Renault a disqualification suspended until the end of 2011. Briatore was banned indefinitely and Symonds for five years; Piquet had immunity and Alonso was found not involved.20223 The team was not fined but paid for the investigation and made a significant contribution to FIA safety projects.32022 The FIA also refused licences to any team employing Briatore and superlicence renewals to drivers he managed.2220

«They not only compromised the integrity of the sport but also endangered the lives of spectators, officials, other competitors and Nelson Piquet Jr. himself.»20223

FIA World Council decision · 21.09.2009

«I bitterly regret my actions to follow the orders I was given.»one source: 21

Nelson Piquet Jr. · statement, 21.09.2009

On 24 September ING and Mutua Madrileña ended their contracts with the team.2324 On 5 January 2010 a Paris court ruled the sanctions on Briatore and Symonds unlawful: they had not been allowed a proper defence, the decision relied on anonymous evidence, and neither held an FIA licence. The court did not examine the conspiracy itself.2926252527 The damages were token; sources differ on the amounts.sources disagree: 282527 On 12 April 2010 the parties settled: both accepted a share of responsibility and agreed not to hold operational roles in Formula 1 until the end of 2012.2930

  1. 30.07.2009Piquet Jr. gives the FIA a sworn statement in Paris.310
  2. 18.08.2009Renault announces Grosjean will replace Piquet.141315
  3. 27–28.08.2009Belgian GP stewards interview Renault staff.313
  4. 11.09.2009Renault and Briatore file a criminal complaint in France against both Piquets.1617315
  5. 16.09.2009Renault does not contest the charges; Briatore and Symonds leave.1617315
  6. 21.09.2009The FIA World Council rules.20223
  7. 24.09.2009ING and Mutua Madrileña end their team contracts.2324
  8. 05.01.2010A Paris court overturns the sanctions on Briatore and Symonds.292625
  9. 12.04.2010Settlement with the FIA.2930

A title by one point

Hamilton won the 2008 title on 98 points to Massa's 97.one source: 2 Had the Singapore result been cancelled, Hamilton would have lost his 6 points for third and Massa nothing: 92 to 97.one source: 2

In March 2023 Bernie Ecclestone told F1-Insider that he and Max Mosley knew about the crash during the 2008 season and chose to do nothing to protect the sport.3112 He later said he did not remember giving that interview.one source: 32

In 2024 Massa sued the FIA, Formula One Management and Ecclestone in the High Court in London for about £64m.3334 Sources give different filing dates.sources disagree: 3334 In November 2025 a judge refused to revisit the championship result but let part of the claim go on.3536 By March 2026 only the conspiracy claim remained, and the point of law went to the UK Supreme Court.3734 The hearing there is set for 2–3 February 2027.3438

«The present claim cannot of course rewrite the outcome of the 2008 drivers' world championship.»3536

Mr Justice Jay, High Court, London · 20.11.2025

In May 2025 Flavio Briatore, an adviser at Alpine, temporarily took over the duties of team principal at the team that grew out of that same Renault.3940

Where the sources disagree

Lap of the crash

Lap 14 per the FIA decision and the lap data; lap 13 in some reports. [3, 20, 7, 6]

Rosberg's and Kubica's penalties

Stop-go according to the BBC and GrandPrix.com, or drive-through according to Motor Sport. [9, 7, 6]

Ferrari mechanics

GrandPrix.com says Massa «knocked down four»; Motor Sport says he «took out one». [7, 6]

Whose idea

Piquet says Symonds and Briatore proposed the crash. Symonds says the idea was Piquet's own. [3, 18, 19]

2010 damages

Sky reports €15,000 and €5,000, AP gives the sums in dollars; the FIA stressed that the main claims were rejected. [28, 25, 27]

Massa's claim

Filed on 11.03.2024 according to Reuters, or 24.03.2024 according to the Supreme Court case page. [33, 34]

Sources

Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.

  1. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 2008 Singapore Grand Prix results and laps”
  2. Jolpica (Ergast): “Jolpica F1 API — 2008 drivers' standings”
  3. FIA World Motor Sport Council (full text published by Crash.net), 2009-09-21: “WMSC decision on Renault F1, Singapore Grand Prix 2008 ('Singapore-gate' verdict)”
  4. Autosport, 2019-04-13: “'Crashgate' revisited — F1's tainted 800th race”
  5. Motor Sport, 2013-09-18: “I was there when... 2008 Singapore GP” (Simon Arron)
  6. Motor Sport, 2008-09-29: “2008 Singapore Grand Prix report” (Ed Foster)
  7. GrandPrix.com, 2008-09-28: “Singapore GP, 2008 — race report”
  8. Crash.net, 2008-09-28: “Singapore 2008: Alonso wins 'lost' race”
  9. BBC (BBC Sport), 2009-01-27: “F1 to scrap 'bad' pit lane rule”
  10. GrandPrix.com, 2009-09-10: “Nelson Piquet's FIA statement revealed”
  11. Crash.net, 2009-09-10: “Transcript of Nelson Piquet Jr's statement to the FIA”
  12. Autosport, 2023-04-05: “How the FIA found out about Crashgate at Brazil 2008 F1 finale, but could not act” (Jonathan Noble)
  13. Autosport, 2009-09-17: “Analysis: how Renault case came to light” (Jonathan Noble)
  14. RTÉ, 2009-08-18: “Renault give Grosjean his big chance”
  15. BBC (BBC Sport), 2009-09-16: “Renault blames Briatore & Symonds”
  16. GrandPrix.com, 2009-09-11: “Renault and Briatore to take legal action against Piquets”
  17. Sky Sports, 2009-09-11: “Renault launch law suits”
  18. Autosport, 2009-09-23: “Symonds will 'always regret' his actions” (Jonathan Noble)
  19. Crash.net, 2009-09-23: “Symonds expresses 'eternal regret' over 'misguided devotion'”
  20. BBC (BBC Sport), 2009-09-21: “Renault handed suspended F1 ban”
  21. BBC (BBC Sport), 2009-09-21: “Piquet Jr 'sorry' for race-fixing”
  22. Sky Sports, 2009-09-21: “Suspended ban for Renault”
  23. AP (via HeraldNet), 2009-09-24: “Renault F1 team loses 2 sponsors for deliberate crash” (Harold Heckle)
  24. Sky Sports, 2009-09-24: “ING end Renault deal”
  25. AP (via The Honolulu Advertiser), 2010-01-05: “Auto racing: Court overturns Briatore's ban, FIA may appeal”
  26. GrandPrix.com, 2010-01-05: “Flavio Briatore wins court case against FIA”
  27. GrandPrix.com, 2010-01-05: “The FIA's reaction”
  28. Sky Sports, 2010-01-05: “Briatore ban overturned”
  29. Adam Cooper's F1 Blog, 2010-04-12: “Briatore's 'lifetime ban' now lasts only until end of 2012” (Adam Cooper)
  30. F1Technical, 2010-04-12: “FIA reaches settlement with Flavio Briatore and Pat Symonds”
  31. F1-Insider, 2023-03-01: “Ecclestone bricht Schweigen über F1-Skandal: Schumacher wäre alleiniger Rekordweltmeister” (Ralf Bach)
  32. RacingNews365, 2023-08-18: “Ecclestone "cannot remember" key Crashgate interview”
  33. Reuters (via The Star), 2024-03-12: “Motor racing — Massa takes action against F1, FIA, Ecclestone in London High Court”
  34. The Supreme Court (UK): “Massa and others (Respondents) v Formula One Management Limited (Appellant) — case UKSC/2026/0035”
  35. ESPN (PA), 2025-11-20: “Massa's £64m court claim over 2008 F1 title can go to trial - judge”
  36. Reuters (via The Star), 2025-11-20: “Motor racing — Part of Massa's UK lawsuit against F1, FIA and Ecclestone can continue”
  37. Sky Sports, 2026-03-07: “Felipe Massa: courts order FIA, Bernie Ecclestone and Formula One Management to pay former Ferrari F1 driver £250,000” (Amar Mehta)
  38. Grande Prêmio, 2026-10-21: “Massa's £64m F1 lawsuit faces decisive Supreme Court hearing over 2008 title” (JP Nascimento)
  39. GrandPrix.com, 2025-05-07: “Oakes resigns as Alpine F1 Team Principal”
  40. PlanetF1, 2025-05-06: “Oliver Oakes in shock Alpine resignation; Flavio Briatore takes charge” (Elizabeth Blackstock)

More stories

All stories →
  • 2008São Paulo · Upset

    Brazil 2008: a title decided at the last corner

    Felipe Massa won at home and for a matter of seconds was champion. Then late rain, Timo Glock on dry tyres and Lewis Hamilton's pass at Junção settled the season by a single point.

    50 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 28
    • sources disagree: 0
  • 2007Scandal

    Spygate 2007: how McLaren lost $100 million

    780 pages of Ferrari secrets, a copy shop in Woking, a row in Budapest and a record FIA fine. How McLaren were thrown out of the constructors' championship while their drivers kept every point.

    33 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 10
    • sources disagree: 1
  • 2021Abu Dhabi · Scandal

    Abu Dhabi 2021: the one lap that decided a championship

    Latifi's crash, the race director's call on lapped cars and Verstappen's last-lap pass. How the 2021 finale became modern Formula 1's loudest officiating row, and what it cost Michael Masi.

    39 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 16
    • sources disagree: 0
  • 2005Indianapolis · Scandal

    Indianapolis 2005: the six-car Grand Prix

    Michelin's tyres could not cope with the final banking, talks over a chicane collapsed, and 14 cars peeled into the pits after the formation lap. How F1 was booed in America, and what came of it.

    36 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 13
    • sources disagree: 1