A package from Maranello
The 2007 season should have been remembered for the McLaren–Ferrari duel on track. Instead the year's main battle was fought by lawyers, and it ended with the biggest fine in motor racing history.78
It started with Nigel Stepney. The Briton had spent years at Ferrari, where he began as chief mechanic.319 Before the 2007 Monaco Grand Prix white powder was found near the fuel tanks of the Ferrari cars, and talk of sabotage began inside the team; Stepney denied everything and said he was being set up.3205 In early July Ferrari sacked him.35
The same week it emerged where Maranello's secrets might have gone. McLaren announced that at the end of April one of its senior technical staff had received a package of technical information from a Ferrari employee, and that the staff member had been suspended.35 He turned out to be Mike Coughlan, McLaren's chief designer, who had once worked with Stepney at Benetton.35
The copy shop that broke it open
On 3 July 2007, under the authority of the High Court of England and Wales, Coughlan's home was searched.145 Some 780 pages of confidential Ferrari material were found there.145

Ferrari was put on the trail by a photocopying shop.45 According to The Independent, the shop was in Woking: Coughlan's wife was copying the documents there, and a member of staff, noticing they were confidential, alerted Ferrari.1one source: 5 The shop's records indicated the documents had been copied or scanned on or around 2–3 May.1one source: 4
On 10 July the case of Ferrari v Coughlan reached the High Court in London. Ferrari's barrister Nigel Tozzi said the Coughlans had "behaved disgracefully by taking these documents."56
First verdict: guilty, but unpunished
On 26 July the FIA World Motor Sport Council (WMSC) found McLaren in breach of Article 151c of the International Sporting Code for possessing confidential Ferrari information.21 It imposed no penalty, ruling there was insufficient evidence that the information had been used.21 But the FIA reserved the right to reopen the case. If it turned out that Ferrari's secrets had been put to use, McLaren faced exclusion from the 2007 and 2008 championships.21
That seemed to be the end of it. The next blow came from inside McLaren.
A morning in Hungary
In Budapest relations within the team finally cracked. On Saturday Fernando Alonso was stripped of Pole positionFirst place on the grid. It goes to the fastest driver in qualifying.In the glossary → and dropped five places for impeding Lewis Hamilton in qualifying.1123 On the morning of 5 August, race day, Alonso had a row with McLaren boss Ron Dennis.1112
Accounts of what was said differ. In Dennis's version, an upset Alonso gave no details but mentioned an email from one of the team's engineers; after the conversation Dennis immediately phoned the FIA.1112?sources disagree: 1112 British newspapers, citing witnesses, reported something else: Alonso allegedly demanded "Either make me number one or let me go" and threatened to take the Ferrari information to the FIA.?sources disagree: 1112 Alonso's manager Luis Garcia called the reports "complete rubbish."?sources disagree: 1112 Later, according to Dennis, the manager retracted what had been said and apologised, and after the race Alonso apologised to him in person.1112
On 30 August FIA president Max Mosley wrote to the McLaren drivers offering immunity in exchange for evidence.17 The drivers gave evidence, and their correspondence ended up among the material the council examined in September.17
What the emails said
On 21 March 2007 McLaren test driver Pedro de la Rosa asked Coughlan for the "Red Car's" weight distribution so he could try it in the simulator, and Coughlan replied by text with Ferrari's figures.1one source: 1
On 25 March de la Rosa sent Alonso details of Ferrari's weight distribution, its aerodynamic balance at 250 km/h and the gas Ferrari used to inflate its tyres.1one source: 1 Alonso replied that testing that gas was "very important".1one source: 1 De la Rosa named Stepney as the source and called it "very reliable".1one source: 1 In April de la Rosa also asked Coughlan about Ferrari's braking system.1one source: 1
Italian police, meanwhile, had compiled records of the contact between Coughlan and Stepney. According to the council, between 11 March and 3 July 2007 they exchanged at least 288 text messages and 35 phone calls.1one source: 1
13 September: 100 million
The extraordinary WMSC meeting at the FIA's Paris headquarters lasted all day.1one source: 7 The ruling was harsh: McLaren were excluded from the 2007 constructors' championship and stripped of all their points for the season; on top of that, the team had to pay a fine of US$100 million, minus the sum Formula One Management would have paid it for its constructors' result.17 Autosport called it by far the largest fine ever imposed in motor racing; Sky Sports called it unprecedented.78
The drivers were spared. Alonso and Hamilton kept all their points and could keep fighting for the title; the only restriction was that no McLaren representative could appear on the podium.179 In its decision the council wrote that "some degree of sporting advantage was obtained", even if it might never be quantified.1one source: 1
Dennis disagreed: "Having been at the hearing today I do not accept that we deserved to be penalised in this way," he said.1one source: 9 McLaren accepted that Coughlan had held Ferrari documents but insisted the information had not been shared with anyone else or used on its cars.913

The irony was that four days before the verdict McLaren had scored a one-two at Monza: Alonso first, Hamilton second.2410 After that race Hamilton led the standings on 92 points, with Alonso on 89 and Kimi Räikkönen on 74.2410
No appeal
On 21 September McLaren notified the FIA that it would not appeal, which handed the constructors' title to Ferrari.1314 "We believe the time has come to put this huge distraction behind us," Dennis said.1314
The season ended with a twist nobody foresaw. Räikkönen became champion with 110 points, while Hamilton and Alonso scored 109 each.1one source: 21 Ferrari won the constructors' championship with 204 points, and McLaren appear in the table as excluded, with zero.1one source: 22

An apology and a full stop
The FIA still had to check whether McLaren's 2008 car contained any Ferrari ideas. On 5 December 2007 McLaren Group chief operating officer Martin Whitmarsh wrote to Mosley.151617 The team admitted that some Ferrari information may have reached people beyond de la Rosa and Alonso, apologised "unreservedly", and offered to discuss a moratorium on systems linked to that data: quickshift, fast fill and CO2 as a tyre gas.151617
That was enough for the FIA. The council cancelled the hearing scheduled for 14 February 2008, and the case was closed.1617 Ferrari accepted the outcome at a sporting level but kept up legal action against individuals in Italy and Britain.1617
The final word came in Italy. In September 2010 the Modena court, sitting in Sassuolo, approved Stepney's plea bargain: a 20-month suspended prison sentence.1819 He was found guilty of offences including sabotage and espionage.1819
Where the sources disagree
According to Ron Dennis, as reported by Reuters (Autosport), Alonso gave no details and only mentioned an email from a team engineer. The Guardian, citing witnesses, reported that Alonso demanded "Either make me number one or let me go" and threatened to take the information to the FIA; his manager Luis Garcia called the reports "complete rubbish". [11, 12]
Sources
Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.
- FIA World Motor Sport Council (text published by Autosport), 2007-09-13: “The full decision by the FIA WMSC (decision of 13 September 2007)”
- Autosport, 2007-07-26: “FIA imposes no penalty on McLaren”
- Autosport, 2007-07-03: “Analysis: the remarkable Stepneygate saga (Adam Cooper)”
- Autosport, 2007-07-10: “Analysis: Ferrari see Coughlan in court (Biranit Goren)”
- NZ Herald / The Independent, 2007-07-10: “Ferrari sues McLaren over information dossier (Ian Herbert, David Tremayne / The Independent)”
- GrandPrix.com, 2007-07-10: “July 10, 2007 — Ferrari SpA v Coughlan opens in the High Court”
- Autosport, 2007-09-13: “McLaren lose 2007 points, fined $100m (Steve Cooper, Jonathan Noble)”
- Sky Sports, 2007-09-14: “Record fine for McLaren”
- The Register, 2007-09-14: “McLaren fined $100m (decision report)”
- Deseret News / Associated Press, 2007-09-13: “McLaren stripped of constructors' points and fined $100 million in Formula One spy case (AP)”
- Autosport / Reuters, 2007-09-15: “Alonso row led to McLaren's downfall (Alan Baldwin)”
- Mail & Guardian / The Guardian, 2007-09-15: “Alonso threatened to expose McLaren (Guardian Unlimited)”
- Autosport, 2007-09-21: “McLaren won't appeal WMSC verdict”
- TNT Sports (Eurosport archive), 2007-09-21: “McLaren rule out appeal”
- McLaren (text published by Autosport), 2007-12-13: “The full letter from McLaren to the FIA (Martin Whitmarsh, 5 December 2007)”
- The Irish Times, 2007-12-18: “FIA draw line under F1 spying scandal”
- NZ Herald / Reuters, 2007-12-18: “FIA closes McLaren spy saga (Alan Baldwin, Reuters)”
- Adam Cooper's F1 Blog, 2010-09-29: “Nigel Stepney sentenced in Italy”
- Sky Sports, 2010-09-30: “Suspended sentence for Stepney”
- Crash.net, 2010-09-30: “Stepney sentenced over spygate saga”
- Jolpica F1 API: “2007 final drivers' standings”
- Jolpica F1 API: “2007 final constructors' standings”
- Jolpica F1 API, 2007-08-05: “2007 Hungarian Grand Prix — qualifying and results (round 11)”
- Jolpica F1 API, 2007-09-09: “2007 Italian Grand Prix — results and standings after round 13”




