Six cars on the grid
On 19 June 2005 Formula 1 held the ninth round of the season at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.18 Twenty cars completed the Formation lapA slow lap before the start to warm the tyres and check the systems.In the glossary →, but only six lined up for the start: fourteen drivers on Michelin tyres turned into the Pit laneThe separate road along the pits. A speed limit applies there.In the glossary → and never came back out.12138 Seven of the ten teams refused to race.822 What remained were two Ferraris, two Jordans and two Minardis, all on Bridgestones.18
To understand how it came to this, we have to go back two days.
Friday: two Toyota crashes
On Friday 17 June, Toyota's reserve driver Ricardo Zonta spun off at Turn 5 after feeling a problem at the rear of the car.562 A few minutes later his team-mate Ralf Schumacher crashed. His Toyota went off at the final corner, the banked turn onto the pit straight, in the same place where he had had a big accident a year earlier.5625 "I was approaching the last corner when I felt something go wrong on the left-hand side," Ralf said.56 In both cases the team suspected the tyres.562
Ralf was taken to hospital for checks after complaining of blurred vision.751 In qualifying and the race the second Toyota was driven by Zonta.751
Saturday: the letter that changed everything
On 18 June the heads of Michelin's F1 programme, Pierre Dupasquier and Nick Shorrock, wrote to FIA race director Charlie Whiting: they had been unable to identify the root cause of the failures and had no total assurance that the qualifying tyres could last the race.34 The problem lay in the 2005 rules: the race had to be run on the tyres a car had qualified on.34 Michelin put it plainly: "the race must be performed with the qualifying tyres."34

Meanwhile, Jarno Trulli put his Toyota on Pole positionFirst place on the grid. It goes to the fastest driver in qualifying.In the glossary →.12 That evening Michelin flew 26 tyres to its research base in Akron, Ohio; by Sunday morning the trip had turned up nothing new.1one source: 2
Sunday: talks hit a wall
The Michelin teams wanted a temporary ChicaneA sequence of two or three short corners in alternating directions.In the glossary → before Turn 13 to slow the cars through it.112 Whiting replied in a letter on 19 June. "We are very surprised that this difficulty has arisen," he wrote.34 The FIA offered alternatives: fit different tyres and accept a penalty, or change wheels during the race if safety demanded it.34 The letter ruled out a chicane: it would break the rules and be unfair to the teams that had brought suitable tyres.34
In a statement after the race the FIA explained its refusal: a chicane would have meant changing the circuit without following modern safety procedures.112 The federation said it had offered another route, monitoring speeds in Turn 13 and penalising any excess, but the Michelin teams would only accept if the Bridgestone cars were slowed as well.1one source: 11 The drivers later said in a joint statement that such a speed restriction "would have been impossible to comply with and impossible to police."1one source: 12
FIA president Max Mosley made it clear that a race with a chicane would not count as a round of the world championship.213 Ferrari did not back the chicane.213 Tyre barriers were already being moved from Turn 10 to build one. Whiting warned that the circuit would then lose its homologation and there would be no race at all. The barriers were put back.1one source: 2 Jordan and Minardi initially sided with the Michelin teams but raced in the end. Minardi owner Paul Stoddart explained that he sent his cars out only because Jordan had broken the agreement.213
A race that was booed
After the formation lap fourteen cars peeled off into the pits, pole-sitter Trulli among them.12138 The six Bridgestone runners were left on the grid.12138
Sources disagree on the size of the crowd: Reuters reported 120,000 spectators, History.com about 100,000.?sources disagree: 89 They agree on the reaction: loud booing, and bottles and beer cans flying onto the track.821014 Track president Joie Chitwood said afterwards he could not recall anything like it at any Indianapolis event.1one source: 10
"I am sorry, but we didn't have a choice," said Williams driver Nick Heidfeld.1one source: 13
Michael Schumacher won, with Rubens Barrichello second.18 A lap down came Tiago Monteiro and Narain Karthikeyan (Jordan), and two laps down Christijan Albers and Patrick Friesacher (Minardi).18 It was Schumacher's only win of 2005.1one source: 27 On the podium a subdued Schumacher skipped the champagne spray into the crowd.1one source: 9
Monteiro, who started 17th, took third place: his first and, as his career turned out, only F1 podium.12615 He celebrated with his mechanics and the Jordan fans in yellow. "This was our moment," the Portuguese recalled.1one source: 15

Who was to blame
The two sides immediately started blaming each other. The FIA pointed out that on 1 June it had already written to teams and tyre makers that tyres should be built to be reliable under all circumstances.1113 Michelin replied that it had proposed solutions, including a chicane, that it considered safe, and that the sporting authority had rejected them.1one source: 17

Michelin was not a competitor in the championship, so the FIA could only go after the teams.182 On 29 June the World Motor Sport Council found the seven guilty on two counts: failing to ensure they had suitable tyres (though the council accepted "strong mitigating circumstances"), and wrongfully refusing to start when they had the right to use the pit lane on every lap.182 Three other charges were dropped, including refusing to race under a speed restriction.182 Any penalty was deferred to a meeting on 14 September.182
It never got that far. On 14 July in Monaco the FIA Senate examined new evidence submitted by six of the teams and accepted that they had been contractually bound to follow their tyre supplier's instructions.1920 The Senate recommended cancelling the verdict.1920 On 22 July the council voted overwhelmingly to agree, and the guilty verdicts against the seven teams were cancelled.1one source: 21
Michelin, meanwhile, tried to make amends with the public. On 28 June the company promised to refund tickets for the race and to buy 20,000 tickets for the 2006 US Grand Prix for those who had been in the stands.1617 Michelin stressed it was not legally obliged to do so.1617 A fans' class action against FOM, Michelin and the Speedway was dismissed by a federal judge in June 2006.1one source: 22
What it cost F1 in America
That same evening Chitwood said the Speedway was "monumentally disappointed" and would evaluate its involvement with F1.1one source: 10 The Indianapolis race survived two more seasons, but on 12 July 2007 the Speedway announced it would not be on the 2008 calendar, after eight consecutive Grands Prix since 2000.232425 Speedway boss Tony George said he and Bernie Ecclestone were "unable to agree how to keep Formula One in Indianapolis"; GrandPrix.com reported that the sanctioning fee had become too high for the track.232425
The next US Grand Prix was not held until November 2012, at a new circuit in Austin.1one source: 28 The country waited five years.1one source: 28
Where the sources disagree
Sources
Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.
- Jolpica F1 API, 2005-06-19: “2005 United States Grand Prix — results (round 9)”
- Autosport, 2020-06-19: “Retrospective: How the 2005 United States GP farce unfolded (Adam Cooper)”
- Autosport, 2005-06-19: “Letters exchanged between Michelin, FIA”
- GrandPrix.com, 2005-06-19: “June 19, 2005 — Michelin/FIA correspondence and impasse”
- Toyota F1, 2005-06-17: “Grand Prix of USA 2005 — Friday press release”
- GrandPrix.com, 2005-06-17: “Ralf hits the wall”
- GrandPrix.com, 2005-06-18: “Ralf has to wait for medical clearance”
- Dawn / Reuters, 2005-06-21: “Schumacher claims hollow win (Reuters)”
- History.com: “Controversy at U.S. Grand Prix (This Day in History, June 19)”
- Autosport, 2005-06-19: “IMS to review F1 future at Indy”
- FIA (via Motorsport.com), 2005-06-21: “FIA statement on US GP”
- Motorsport.com, 2005-06-30: “Joint statement by 19 drivers (dated 23 June 2005)”
- Motorsport.com, 2005-06-21: “The blame game — 2005 United States GP at Indianapolis (Anne Proffit)”
- GrandPrix.com, 2005-06-19: “Race incidents from Indianapolis”
- Motor Sport Magazine, 2020-06-19: “Tiago Monteiro: the only man who cheered at the 2005 US Grand Prix (Damien Smith)”
- Autosport, 2005-06-28: “Michelin offers US GP tickets refund”
- Modern Tire Dealer, 2005-06-28: “Michelin offers to reimburse F1 race spectators”
- GrandPrix.com, 2005-06-29: “World Council decision (June 29, 2005)”
- Autosport, 2005-07-14: “FIA Senate absolves Michelin teams”
- Pitpass (FIA statement), 2005-07-14: “FIA issues new statement re Michelin teams”
- Autosport, 2005-07-22: “FIA cancels US GP verdict”
- Autosport, 2006-06-17: “US GP class action lawsuit dismissed”
- Indianapolis Motor Speedway (via Motorsport.com), 2007-07-12: “IMS statement on 2008”
- GrandPrix.com, 2007-07-12: “Goodbye Indianapolis”
- Jolpica F1 API: “Races at Indianapolis; 2008–2012 calendars”
- Jolpica F1 API: “Tiago Monteiro — all results”
- Jolpica F1 API: “Michael Schumacher — 2005 wins”
- Jolpica F1 API: “2012 season calendar”




