Menu

Scandal · Austrian Grand Prix 2002

Austria 2002: the win given away over the radio

Rubens Barrichello led the whole race and, a few metres from the line, let Michael Schumacher through on Ferrari's orders. Jeering grandstands, an upside-down podium, a million-dollar fine and a ban on team orders that lasted eight seasons.

Date
12 May 2002
Circuit
Spielberg
Read
8 min
A red Ferrari car in a museum display against a backdrop of flames.
A Ferrari F2002 show car at the National Automobile Museum in Turin, 2020.

Eight laps from home

On 12 May 2002 the A1-Ring at Spielberg hosted the sixth round of the world championship.134 Michael Schumacher arrived in Austria as the clear favourite: he had won four of the season's five races.2622 But this weekend belonged to his team-mate. Rubens Barrichello took Pole positionFirst place on the grid. It goes to the fastest driver in qualifying.In the glossary → and led almost the entire race.345

Both Ferraris were on two-stop strategies. On lap 61 Barrichello pitted, Schumacher led for a single lap, then stopped on the next lap himself, and the Brazilian was back in front.47 According to Ferrari sporting director Jean Todt, that was when, on lap 63 of 71, the drivers were told to swap places.37

Schumacher, meanwhile, kept pushing: in the closing laps it was he who set the race's fastest lap, chipping away at his team-mate's lead.34 Nobody behind the two Ferraris was a threat; the Williams cars of Montoya and Ralf Schumacher finished more than 17 seconds back.15

Barrichello started the final lap about a second ahead. Out of the last corner he braked sharply, and Schumacher slipped past just before the line. The gap at the flag was 0.182 seconds.145

Two red Ferraris on the finishing straight, with marshals and photographers at the fence in the foreground.
Rubens Barrichello makes way for Michael Schumacher on the finishing straight at the Austrian Grand Prix, 12 May 2002.

The grandstands answered with jeers.456

An upside-down podium

What came next angered more than just the spectators. Schumacher ushered Barrichello onto the top step of the podium, so the Brazilian stood there while the German anthem played. For the Italian anthem they stood there together. Schumacher took the winner's trophy from Austrian Chancellor Wolfgang Schüssel without acknowledging him, and promptly handed it to his team-mate.9104

A silver cup on a dark base in a display case.
The 2002 Austrian Grand Prix second-place trophy in Michael Schumacher's private collection (photographed in 2019).

Both drivers looked as if they had been caught out. "I was asked to move over. It was a team decision and I have to respect it," said Barrichello.one source: 6 Schumacher kept his distance too: "But obviously I don't take a lot of joy from the victory."56 He added that before the race, when asked about team tactics, he had said: "I don't believe that there is going to be a team strategy involved." And then, as he put it, he was suddenly told that Rubens would move over.one source: 5

Todt was not about to apologise. "I am not really bothered. Sometimes difficult decisions have to be taken," he said when asked about the crowd's reaction.one source: 5 His main argument: in 1997, 1998 and 1999 Ferrari had lost the championship at the final race of the season.510 Technical director Ross Brawn admitted the swap could have been hidden behind Pit stopA stop in the pits, most often to change tyres.In the glossary → tactics, but doing it covertly, he said, "would have taken credit away from Rubens".one source: 3

What was at stake was four points: ten for the win instead of six for second.38 After Austria Schumacher had 54 points, twice as many as his nearest pursuer, Juan Pablo Montoya, on 27. Barrichello was fourth with 12.236

The second time

For Barrichello the bitterest part was that he had been here before. A year earlier, at the same circuit, he had obeyed a team order on the final lap and handed Schumacher second place behind David Coulthard.232425 And shortly before the 2002 race he had signed a new Ferrari contract running to the end of 2004.527

The paddock did not mince its words. "It was absolutely disgraceful," said Renault team principal Flavio Briatore. Williams technical director Patrick Head called it "a cynical manoeuvre".one source: 5

The story, years later

Barrichello only said more later. In 2008, on the Brazilian programme Fantástico, he claimed he was given an ultimatum on the final lap: "I was told to think about my contract."1819 In 2012, speaking to Globo, he called the finish "eight laps of war" and recalled screaming on the radio that he would not let his team-mate pass.2022

Todt's account has shifted with time too. Twenty-four years ago he spoke of a decision passed on to the drivers eight laps from the end. In 2026, on the High Performance podcast, Todt said there had been an agreement before the start.sources disagree: 3721 As he put it, the rule was: "if you are in front of Michael before the last pit stop, you must let Michael go". The embarrassment, Todt says, came from Rubens not wanting to stick to what had been agreed.one source: 21

A million for the ceremony

On 26 June 2002 the FIA World Motor Sport Council heard the case. It could not punish the team orders themselves: both drivers were contractually bound to follow them, and the council described a team's right to decide its drivers' finishing order as "long-standing and traditional".910 Breaching the podium procedure, Article 170 of the sporting regulations, was another matter, and it cost one million US dollars. The fine was imposed jointly on Ferrari, Schumacher and Barrichello: half payable immediately, the other half suspended for a year.910

FIA president Max Mosley conceded that "what happened in Austria was bad from a sporting point of view", but said the council had no legal grounds to punish it.one source: 10 According to Mosley, the FIA received more faxes and emails from fans after the race than after Ayrton Senna's death in 1994.one source: 10

A ban that lasted eight seasons

On 28 October 2002 the Formula One Commission wrote a short sentence into the rules: team orders which interfere with a race result are prohibited. It applied from the 2003 season.111222

The 2002 championship never needed those four Austrian points. After the French Grand Prix on 21 July Schumacher had 96 points to Montoya's 34, with six rounds left. The title was his. He finished the year on 144 points to Barrichello's 77.one source: 2829

Team orders did not disappear after the ban; they just got quieter. At the 2007 Brazilian Grand Prix Felipe Massa ceded a potential win to Kimi Räikkönen at the pit stops, and the Finn became champion.one source: 13 In July 2010 at Hockenheim it happened in the open again. Massa's engineer Rob Smedley radioed: "Fernando is faster than you. Can you confirm you understood that message?" On lap 49 Fernando Alonso passed Massa.one source: 16 The StewardsThe race judges. They review incidents and hand out penalties.In the glossary → fined Ferrari $100,000.151617

This time the FIA decided not to fight what it could not police. On 10 December 2010, at a meeting in Monaco, the World Motor Sport Council deleted Article 39.1, which had banned team orders. Teams were simply reminded that actions bringing the sport into disrepute remain punishable under Article 151c of the International Sporting Code.131415

So from 2011 what Ferrari did at Spielberg was once again within the rules. What is forbidden is doing it in a way that brings the sport into disrepute.131415

Where the sources disagree

When the swap was agreed

In 2002 Todt said the drivers were told on lap 63, after the final pit stops, as Grandprix.com and Autosport reported. In 2026, on the High Performance podcast as reported by Crash.net, he said the agreement had been in place before the start. [3, 7, 21]

Sources

Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.

  1. Jolpica F1 API, 2002-05-12: “2002 Austrian Grand Prix — results (round 6)”
  2. Jolpica F1 API, 2002-05-12: “2002 driver standings after round 6”
  3. Grandprix.com, 2002-05-12: “Austrian GP, 2002 — race report”
  4. BBC Sport, 2002-05-12: “Lap by lap: Austrian GP”
  5. The Guardian, 2002-05-13: “Fury over stitch-up for Schumacher victory (Alan Henry)”
  6. Associated Press via Lawrence Journal-World, 2002-05-13: “A gift for Schumacher: the Austrian Grand Prix (Susanna Loof, AP)”
  7. Autosport, 2002-06-01: “Ferrari's Austria debacle”
  8. Motor Sport, 2002-07: “Modern Times: Schumacher's Spielberg gift (Simon Taylor)”
  9. Autosport (FIA statement), 2002-06-26: “The full statement by the World Council”
  10. ESPN, 2002-06-26: “Ferrari, Schumacher, Barrichello fined $1 million (AP)”
  11. Grandprix.com, 2002-10-28: “The F1 Commission in detail”
  12. RaceFans, 2010-12-13: “Stewards get new powers to act on driving standards”
  13. Grandprix.com, 2010-12-10: “F1 Team Orders Ban Is Lifted”
  14. Adam Cooper's F1 Blog, 2010-12-10: “Team orders rule dropped as FIA relies on 151c (Adam Cooper)”
  15. RTÉ Sport, 2010-12-10: “Team orders ban deleted from F1 rulebook”
  16. UPI, 2010-07-25: “Ferrari fined for German Grand Prix finish”
  17. Speedcafe, 2010-07-26: “Ferrari fined $100,000 for team orders”
  18. Grandprix.com, 2008-11-25: “The truth will out (Barrichello on Fantástico)”
  19. Crash.net, 2022-03-30: “Rubens: I was told to consider my contract”
  20. Nextgen-Auto, 2012-05-10: “Barrichello reveals Ferrari threat of 2002 (GMM, citing Globo)”
  21. Crash.net, 2026-04-25: “How Rubens Barrichello 'embarrassed' Ferrari in F1 team orders fiasco (Todt on the High Performance Podcast)”
  22. Motor Sport, 2022-05-12: “Austria '02: How Ferrari team orders controversy embarrassed F1 (Edward Hardy)”
  23. Grandprix.com, 2001-05-14: “Barrichello still waiting for pay-back from Schumacher”
  24. Autosport, 2001-05-13: “Unhappy Rubens to talk team orders with Ferrari”
  25. Jolpica F1 API, 2001-05-13: “2001 Austrian Grand Prix — results (round 6)”
  26. Jolpica F1 API, 2002: “2002 season — race winners by round”
  27. PlanetF1, 2025-06-25: “When Ferrari team orders decision triggered furious fan response (Henry Valantine)”
  28. Jolpica F1 API, 2002-07-21: “2002 driver standings after round 11 (French GP)”
  29. Jolpica F1 API, 2002-10-13: “2002 final driver standings”

More stories

All stories →
  • 2005Indianapolis · Scandal

    Indianapolis 2005: the six-car Grand Prix

    Michelin's tyres could not cope with the final banking, talks over a chicane collapsed, and 14 cars peeled into the pits after the formation lap. How F1 was booed in America, and what came of it.

    36 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 13
    • sources disagree: 1
  • 2007Scandal

    Spygate 2007: how McLaren lost $100 million

    780 pages of Ferrari secrets, a copy shop in Woking, a row in Budapest and a record FIA fine. How McLaren were thrown out of the constructors' championship while their drivers kept every point.

    33 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 10
    • sources disagree: 1
  • 1997Jerez · Season finale

    The decider in Jerez

    Schumacher and Villeneuve came to the last race one point apart. On lap 48 Schumacher turned into his rival, went off and lost the title, and a month later the FIA excluded him from the season's standings.

    61 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 47
    • one source: 10
    • sources disagree: 4
  • 2008Singapore · Scandal

    The crash that was ordered

    Nelson Piquet Jr. crashed on purpose to bring out the safety car and help his teammate Alonso win. The truth came out a year later, and the court cases are still going.

    64 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 51
    • one source: 7
    • sources disagree: 6