Menu

Scandal

Benetton 1994: a title under investigation

A hidden menu option in the software, an ignored black flag, a pit-lane fire and a worn plank under the floor. How Michael Schumacher won his first title by a single point, in between FIA hearings.

Read
9 min
Sources
24
Claims
34
A green and light blue Benetton car at speed against a blurred background.
Michael Schumacher in the Benetton B194 at Woodcote, 1994 British Grand Prix, Silverstone.

A season on two fronts

Michael Schumacher began 1994 as if the championship were already settled: he won six of the first seven races and was beaten only in Spain, by Damon Hill.one source: 1 By the autumn, though, the season's main events were happening not on track but in FIA offices. Within a few months Benetton went through an investigation into its software, a black flag at Silverstone, a Pit laneThe separate road along the pits. A speed limit applies there.In the glossary → fire at Hockenheim and a worn plank under the floor at Spa. In the end Schumacher won the title by a single point.718

The black flag at Silverstone

On 10 July, on the Formation lapA slow lap before the start to warm the tyres and check the systems.In the glossary → of the British Grand Prix, Schumacher overtook Pole positionFirst place on the grid. It goes to the fastest driver in qualifying.In the glossary → Hill at least twice. The StewardsThe race judges. They review incidents and hand out penalties.In the glossary → handed him a 5-second stop-go penalty.1020 Benetton were told verbally at 14:27 and officially at 14:31, but Schumacher did not come in. He was then shown the black flag with the number 5 board for three laps in a row. He only served the penalty when the team told him to, having covered at least 14 laps since the notification.1020 On the road Schumacher finished second, and the stewards fined Benetton $25,000.1420

On 26 July the World Motor Sport Council took over the case. Schumacher was excluded from the British Grand Prix results and suspended for two races, and Benetton's fine rose to $500,000.91014 The organisers were punished too: Clerk of the Course Pierre Aumonier had his super licence suspended for a year.one source: 9

Schumacher appealed. On 30 August the FIA International Court of Appeal in Paris upheld the decision in its entirety. It rejected the argument that the driver had not seen the flag: Schumacher himself admitted seeing the number 5 board, which was shown together with the flag. The court called ignoring the black flag "one of the most serious breaches of the Sporting Code". Because the appeal had suspended the penalty, the ban applied to the two Grands Prix following the court's decision.one source: 10 Schumacher missed Italy and Portugal, and Hill won both races.151

Brawn later said: "the black flag is sacrosanct: even if it was unjustified, we had to respect it."one source: 18

Fire at Hockenheim

On 31 July, on lap 15 of the German Grand Prix, Jos Verstappen's car was engulfed in flames during refuelling. Several mechanics and the driver himself suffered burns, fortunately minor ones.21314 On 10 August the FIA stated that a filter had been removed from Benetton's refuelling rig and that this had caused the fire. The team replied that it had permission and blamed a faulty valve.1423 According to the FIA, without the filter fuel flowed more than 12% faster, which in a refuelling race meant a shorter Pit stopA stop in the pits, most often to change tyres.In the glossary →.one source: 23

A green and light blue Benetton car close up on track.
Jos Verstappen in the Benetton B194, 1994 British Grand Prix, Silverstone.

Who exactly allowed the filter to be removed was never cleared up. In its statement Benetton claimed it had acted with the permission of FIA technical delegate Charlie Whiting, and Brawn said the same ten years later. But at the World Motor Sport Council hearing the defence, led by barrister George Carman, put forward a different version: the filter had been removed by a junior employee without management's knowledge. The council accepted that version.sources disagree: 12181623 Benetton also denied that the missing filter had caused the fire.1219

The hearing took place on Wednesday 7 September, and Benetton received no penalty.1523 FIA president Max Mosley explained that the decision was taken "in the interests of the sport, and in fairness to the other teams who wanted a decision", because otherwise the case would have dragged on until 19 October. Later he admitted: "Maybe we were too easy on Wednesday."one source: 15

The plank at Spa

From the German Grand Prix onwards every car carried a wooden plank under its floor. If it wore away, that meant the car had been running lower than allowed. Spa was only the third race under the new rule.2124

On 28 August Schumacher crossed the line first in Belgium. The new plank was 10mm thick and had to keep at least 9mm by the end of the race. After the finish, a section about 80cm long on Schumacher's car measured 7.4mm.172422 On lap 19 Schumacher had spun and run over a KerbThe striped edging on the side of the track in corners.In the glossary →.1724 Benetton blamed the wear on that, but the stewards decided its nature and location did not match the marks from the spin.one source: 24 Schumacher was DSQDisqualifiedThe result is cancelled for breaking the rules.In the glossary → and the win went to Hill. The Briton only learned of it at Brussels airport.41722

Benetton's appeal over Spa was rejected.1524 According to Motor Sport, the team left the FIA Court of Appeal on 7 September, and Schumacher's lead over Hill stayed at 21 points instead of 35.one source: 15

One point

In total the disqualifications cost Schumacher 16 points: six for second place at Silverstone and ten for the win at Spa.2418 He missed two more races through the ban.151 After Portugal only one point of his lead remained: 76 to 75.one source: 5

A blue and white Williams car close up, the driver in a dark helmet.
Damon Hill in the Williams FW16, 1994 British Grand Prix, Silverstone.

Schumacher returned at Jerez on 16 October and won. Hill answered with victory in Japan, and they arrived at the Adelaide finale at 92 to 91.one source: 16 On 13 November Schumacher clipped the wall and then collided with Hill. Both retired after 35 laps, and Schumacher became world champion by a single point.718 The constructors' title, meanwhile, went to Williams: 118 points to Benetton's 103.one source: 8

What 1994 left behind

No investigation proved that Benetton had raced with banned electronics.1113 The team was not punished over the filter.1523 The penalties for Silverstone and Spa concerned breaches the FIA considered proven, and appeals changed nothing there.one source: 101524 Yet even Brawn admitted that a season of hearings cast a shadow over the title: "I was very frustrated because it tainted a fantastic achievement."one source: 18

Where the sources disagree

Who allowed the filter's removal

Benetton's statement, and later Ross Brawn speaking to Motor Sport, said the filter was removed with the permission of FIA technical delegate Charlie Whiting. At the World Motor Sport Council hearing the defence said a junior employee had removed it without management's knowledge (as Motor Sport and RaceFans report), and the council accepted that version. [12, 18, 16, 23]

Sources

Footnote numbers are the numbers of the sources in this list.

  1. Jolpica F1 API, 1994: “1994 season — race winners by round”
  2. Jolpica F1 API, 1994-07-10: “1994 British Grand Prix — results (round 8)”
  3. Jolpica F1 API, 1994-07-31: “1994 German Grand Prix — results (round 9)”
  4. Jolpica F1 API, 1994-08-28: “1994 Belgian Grand Prix — results (round 11)”
  5. Jolpica F1 API, 1994-09-25: “1994 driver standings after round 13 (Portugal)”
  6. Jolpica F1 API, 1994-11-06: “1994 driver standings after round 15 (Japan)”
  7. Jolpica F1 API, 1994-11-13: “1994 Australian Grand Prix — results (round 16)”
  8. Jolpica F1 API, 1994-11-13: “1994 final driver and constructor standings”
  9. FIA via Motorsport.com, 1994-07-26: “FIA disciplinary ruling press release (World Motor Sport Council, Paris, 26 July 1994)”
  10. FIA, 1994-08-30: “International Court of Appeal: ONS for Michael Schumacher v. WMSC decision of 26 July 1994 (hearing of 30 August 1994)”
  11. FIA via Motorsport.com, 1994-07-29: “Benetton launch control: FIA press release (Hockenheim, 29 July 1994)”
  12. Benetton via Motorsport.com, 1994-08: “Benetton press release on the Hockenheim refuelling fire”
  13. Motor Sport, 1994-09: “Benetton in the dock”
  14. Motor Sport, 1994-09: “The month in Motor Sport”
  15. Motor Sport, 1994-10: “Diary of a somebody (pp. 20–21)”
  16. Motor Sport, 1994-10: “Diary of a somebody — page 21 (same article as s15)”
  17. Motor Sport, 1994-10: “As thick as a plank (Belgian GP report)”
  18. Motor Sport, 2004-12: “That was 1994: season recap with Ross Brawn”
  19. Motor Sport, 2004-12: “Pit flashpoint”
  20. Grandprix.com, 1994-07-10: “British GP, 1994 — race report”
  21. Grandprix.com, 1994-07-31: “German GP, 1994 — race report”
  22. Grandprix.com, 1994-08-28: “Belgian GP, 1994 — race report”
  23. RaceFans, 2014-08-14: “Benetton bounce back as Schumacher and Verstappen deliver double podium (Keith Collantine)”
  24. The Race, 2023-10-24: “Why F1's first plank DSQ was far more controversial (Glenn Freeman)”

More stories

All stories →
  • 1997Jerez · Season finale

    The decider in Jerez

    Schumacher and Villeneuve came to the last race one point apart. On lap 48 Schumacher turned into his rival, went off and lost the title, and a month later the FIA excluded him from the season's standings.

    61 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 47
    • one source: 10
    • sources disagree: 4
  • 2002Spielberg · Scandal

    Austria 2002: the win given away over the radio

    Rubens Barrichello led the whole race and, a few metres from the line, let Michael Schumacher through on Ferrari's orders. Jeering grandstands, an upside-down podium, a million-dollar fine and a ban on team orders that lasted eight seasons.

    35 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 23
    • one source: 11
    • sources disagree: 1
  • 2005Indianapolis · Scandal

    Indianapolis 2005: the six-car Grand Prix

    Michelin's tyres could not cope with the final banking, talks over a chicane collapsed, and 14 cars peeled into the pits after the formation lap. How F1 was booed in America, and what came of it.

    36 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 13
    • sources disagree: 1
  • 2007Scandal

    Spygate 2007: how McLaren lost $100 million

    780 pages of Ferrari secrets, a copy shop in Woking, a row in Budapest and a record FIA fine. How McLaren were thrown out of the constructors' championship while their drivers kept every point.

    33 claims checked

    • two or more sources: 22
    • one source: 10
    • sources disagree: 1